Alright guys, I kinda feel dumb on this one. My rear main cap is grooved. Well I didn't have the driver's side top of the seal in the groove. That cause the seal to bulge. The bad thing is, I cut the seal again before I figured that out. It still leaked, but less. So I got another one, but I'll have to do it tomorrow. Hopefully it'll work with out cutting the tabs.
BTW, the Fel-Pro gaskets had a piece of paper with installation instructions on it. It said that there were 2 types of rear caps. A grooved and a non-grooved. With the grooved, you had to trim all but 1/16" of the vertical tabs, because of the rear main seal's wings. With the non-grooved you left the vertical tabs because the rear main seal didn't have wings. My rear main doesn't have wings, so I'm going to leave them on and try it. Thanks again guys. John